Email Marketing

Sunset Flows: Re-Engaging or Suppressing Inactive Subscribers

How to build a sunset flow that defines inactivity without inflated Apple opens, gives disengaged subscribers one last chance, then suppresses them safely.

TL;DR
  • A sunset flow gives subscribers who stopped engaging a short, final sequence, then stops marketing to anyone who still does not respond. It protects inbox placement for the people who do buy.
  • Since Apple Mail Privacy Protection, opens no longer prove anyone read your email. Define engagement with clicks, site activity, orders and opens you can trust.
  • Suppress, do not delete, and measure the flow on what it saves: deliverability, list costs and the revenue of the subscribers you keep.

What is a sunset flow, and why does it protect revenue?

A sunset flow is an automated sequence for email subscribers who have stopped engaging. It makes one last attempt to win back their attention. Anyone who still does not respond is moved out of your regular sends. It is the practical way to run a sunset policy, the rule that decides when a subscriber is no longer worth mailing.

It can feel wrong to shrink a list on purpose. But mailing people who never engage costs you in three ways:

  • Inbox placement. Mailbox providers watch how recipients react to your mail. When a large share ignores or deletes it, more of your email can land in spam, including for your best customers.
  • Spam complaints. Disengaged subscribers are the most likely to hit “report spam.” Google’s sender guidelines for bulk senders (more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail addresses) ask senders to keep the spam rate below 0.3%, and Yahoo has similar requirements.
  • List cost. Most email platforms price by profiles or contacts, so dead weight raises your bill.

A sunset flow is list hygiene that runs on its own. Our guide to email deliverability on Shopify covers authentication and the rest of the deliverability foundations.

Why can’t you define inactivity with opens anymore?

Apple Mail Privacy Protection, launched with iOS 15 in 2021, preloads email content for users who turn it on. That can register an open whether or not anyone read the message. A subscriber who has not looked at your emails in a year can still show regular opens.

If your sunset rule is “no opens in 90 days,” those subscribers never qualify, and the flow misses the people it was built for. Your open rate also stops being a reliable signal on its own.

Define engagement with signals a mail client cannot fake:

Signal Reliable? Notes
Email clicks Yes Some security scanners click links automatically, so watch for odd spikes
Orders Yes The strongest signal of all
Site activity (viewed product, added to cart) Yes Needs onsite tracking tied to the profile
SMS clicks or replies Yes Shows the person is active with your brand
Opens flagged as non-Apple-privacy Partly Useful, but still not proof of a read
All opens No Inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection
Recent signup Yes New subscribers should never enter a sunset flow

In Klaviyo, Opened Email events carry an “Apple Privacy Open” property. Its help center shows how to add “Apple Privacy Open is false” to the open condition in a segment. Profiles then count as engaged only through a non-privacy open, a click, an order or a recent signup. Other email service providers have their own ways to separate these opens, so check yours.

How long should someone be inactive before they enter the flow?

Tie the window to how often your customers buy. A store that sells coffee subscriptions sees engaged buyers every month. A store that sells mattresses may not hear from a happy customer for years, and that customer may still open a well-timed email.

Store type (illustrative) Typical buying cycle Suggested inactivity window
Consumables (coffee, supplements, skincare) 1 to 3 months 90 to 120 days
Fashion and accessories 3 to 6 months 120 to 180 days
Home goods and gifts 6 to 12 months 180 to 270 days
High-ticket, rare purchases 12 months or more 270 to 365 days

These are starting points. Check them against your own data: look at past buyers who went quiet and then purchased again, and see how long the quiet period usually lasted. Set the window beyond that.

A typical entry segment, written in plain language:

  • Subscribed to email for at least the inactivity window.
  • No clicks in that window.
  • No orders in that window.
  • No onsite activity (product views, add to cart) in that window.
  • No non-Apple-privacy opens in that window.
  • Not currently in a win-back campaign for lapsed buyers.

How should a sunset flow be structured?

Keep it short. These subscribers have ignored dozens of emails, so a long sequence just adds more unread mail.

Email 1: the check-in

Ask a simple, honest question: do you still want to hear from us? Show one or two of your best sellers or newest products as a reminder of why they signed up. Include a clear button such as “Yes, keep me subscribed.”

Email 2: the preference offer

A few days later, offer choices instead of all or nothing. Fewer emails, only product launches, only sales, or a switch to SMS if they prefer it. Many people stop engaging because they get too much mail, not because they lost interest in the brand. Our guide to email send frequency covers how to set the cadence they choose.

Email 3: the goodbye

Tell them plainly that you will stop emailing them unless they click. Keep the tone warm. A short “We’ll stop emailing you” message often gets more clicks than the previous two.

The exit

After a final wait of a few days, anyone who clicked, bought or browsed leaves the flow and returns to normal sends. Everyone else is suppressed from email marketing.

Should you include a discount? Usually not. An offer that only appears when someone stops engaging teaches subscribers to go quiet. If you want to test one, keep it modest, put it in a single email and measure it against a group that got no offer.

Should you suppress or delete inactive subscribers?

Suppress them. Suppression stops marketing email but keeps the profile, its order history and its consent record. If the person buys again or signs up again, you still know who they are.

In Klaviyo, the help center states that suppressed profiles do not count toward the email plan’s active profile limit. Its bulk tool to “suppress inactive profiles” keeps anyone who clicked or ordered within 182 days. Two details to know:

  • SMS is separate. Email suppression does not change SMS eligibility. If a subscriber is inactive on email but active on SMS, they stay reachable by text.
  • Suppression is not a one-time job. A bulk suppression does not catch profiles that go quiet later. That is why the flow, which runs continuously, beats an occasional manual cleanup.

Deleting profiles is a separate decision, usually driven by data retention or privacy requests. It removes history you may want later, so keep it for those cases.

How do you measure a sunset flow?

A sunset flow should not be judged on revenue alone. Most of its value is in what it prevents. Track:

  • Reactivation rate: the share of entrants who click, browse or buy before the exit.
  • Revenue from reactivated subscribers in the 90 days after they leave the flow.
  • Engagement on regular campaigns: click rate and revenue per recipient should rise once inactive profiles stop diluting them.
  • Spam complaint rate and inbox placement, from Google Postmaster Tools or your provider’s deliverability reports.
  • Profile count and plan cost before and after.

Worked example (illustrative numbers)

All numbers below are illustrative.

A store has 100,000 email subscribers. Using clicks, orders and site activity, 30,000 have shown no engagement in 180 days. Before, every campaign went to all 100,000.

  1. Flow entry: the 30,000 enter the sunset flow over a few weeks as they qualify.
  2. Reactivation: 1,500 (5%) click, browse or buy and return to regular sends.
  3. Suppression: 28,500 are suppressed from email marketing.
  4. Campaign math: a campaign that earned $10,000 from 100,000 recipients earned $0.10 per recipient. If almost all that revenue came from engaged subscribers, the same campaign to 71,500 people might earn close to the same $10,000, about $0.14 per recipient.
  5. Result: similar revenue, fewer sends, fewer complaints, a cleaner sender reputation and a smaller platform bill.

Plug your own list size and revenue into the Revenue per Subscriber calculator to see how much each engaged subscriber is worth.

Sunset flow launch checklist

  • [ ] Engagement is defined by clicks, orders, site activity and non-Apple-privacy opens, not all opens.
  • [ ] The inactivity window matches your buying cycle and is checked against past data.
  • [ ] New subscribers and active SMS subscribers are excluded from the entry segment.
  • [ ] Lapsed buyers in a win-back flow do not also enter the sunset flow.
  • [ ] The flow has two or three emails over one to three weeks.
  • [ ] Email 2 offers a frequency or content preference, not only unsubscribe.
  • [ ] Any click, order or onsite visit exits the flow and restores regular sends.
  • [ ] Non-responders are suppressed, not deleted.
  • [ ] One-click unsubscribe works in every email, and unsubscribes are honored promptly.
  • [ ] Reactivation rate, complaint rate and revenue per recipient are reviewed monthly.

FAQ

What is the difference between a sunset flow and a win-back flow?

A win-back flow targets past customers who have not bought in a while, and its goal is a second or next order. A sunset flow targets subscribers who have stopped engaging with email, whether or not they ever bought, and its goal is to confirm interest or stop mailing them. A lapsed buyer can enter both, so run win-back first. Our guide to win-back emails covers that flow.

Will suppressing subscribers reduce my email revenue?

Usually very little, because inactive subscribers produce little revenue. Revenue per recipient tends to rise, and better inbox placement can lift results for the engaged list. Check this on your own data with a before-and-after comparison.

Can I still reach suppressed subscribers?

Not with marketing email. Order confirmations and shipping notices sent by your store platform are not affected, and subscribers can come back if they re-subscribe through a form or checkout. You can also reach them through other channels where they gave consent, such as SMS.

Turn this into a plan for your store

The Free Profit Audit scans your store, sizes your biggest profit leaks and builds a 90-day plan.

Free Profit Audit