- Marketplaces offer reach and trust but take fees and keep the customer relationship. Your own store gives you data and repeat purchases but requires you to bring the traffic.
- Decide by product role: use marketplaces for discovery and search demand, and your own store for the full range, bundles and loyalty.
- Compare channels by contribution after all fees and marketing, and watch for marketplace sales cannibalizing your own store.
Why is this decision so important?
Many brands start on their own store, then add Amazon or another marketplace. Others start on a marketplace and later build their own store. Either way, the two channels compete for the same customers, budget and inventory.
Getting the balance wrong can mean:
- Paying marketplace fees on customers who would have bought from your store.
- Losing control of pricing and brand presentation.
- Building a customer base you cannot email, retarget or reward.
- Or, in the other direction, missing large amounts of search demand that happens only on marketplaces.
How do marketplaces and your own store compare?
| Factor | Marketplace | Your own store (DTC) |
|---|---|---|
| Traffic | Built-in shopper demand | You must drive traffic |
| Trust | Marketplace brand and fulfillment promises | Your brand, reviews and policies |
| Fees | Referral, fulfillment, advertising and other fees | Payment processing, apps, your own ad spend |
| Customer data | Very limited | Full: email, behavior, purchase history |
| Repeat purchase | Owned by the marketplace experience | You control retention marketing |
| Pricing control | Price competition and parity pressure | Full control |
| Brand experience | Standardized listing format | Fully customized |
Neither is better in all cases. The right mix depends on your category, margin and brand goals.
How do you decide which products go where?
Assign each product (or product group) a role:
- Discovery products: items people search for on marketplaces, which introduce your brand. Good marketplace candidates.
- Hero and bundle products: best experienced with your story, bundles and add-ons. Prioritize your own store.
- Replenishment products: consumables that customers reorder. Where do customers reorder today, and where can you build loyalty? See replenishment emails.
- Exclusive products: limited editions, bundles and new launches that give shoppers a reason to visit your store.
Many brands keep a core range on marketplaces and reserve bundles, exclusives and the full range for their own store.
How should you set prices across channels?
- Account for marketplace fees in the marketplace price.
- Be aware that marketplaces may monitor price competitiveness and that large price gaps can affect visibility. Check each marketplace’s current policies.
- Give shoppers reasons to buy direct that are not only price: exclusive bundles, a loyalty program, better gift options, faster support or free samples.
How do you measure channel profitability?
Compare channels on contribution, not revenue.
Contribution per order = revenue − product cost − channel fees − fulfillment and shipping − returns − marketing attributed to the channel.
Worked example (illustrative numbers): a skincare brand sells a $40 serum.
| Item | Own store | Marketplace |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $40.00 | $40.00 |
| Product cost | $8.00 | $8.00 |
| Channel and payment fees | $1.50 | $6.00 |
| Fulfillment and shipping | $6.50 | $5.50 |
| Advertising per order | $12.00 | $7.00 |
| Contribution per first order | $12.00 | $13.50 |
| 12-month repeat orders per customer | 1.8 | Not directly measurable |
On the first order, the marketplace looks slightly more profitable. But own-store customers place an average of 1.8 more orders in a year, mostly through email at low cost. Over 12 months, the own-store customer is worth much more. The brand keeps the serum on the marketplace for discovery but invests in its own store for repeat customers, adding an insert card in marketplace orders (where marketplace policies allow) that explains the brand’s direct benefits.
See customer lifetime value and contribution margin for eCommerce.
What about cannibalization?
When you launch or grow a marketplace presence, check whether own-store sales fall at the same time. Signs include:
- Branded search traffic shifting from your site to the marketplace.
- Returning customers buying on the marketplace instead of direct.
- Total revenue rising less than marketplace revenue.
Track total business contribution, not each channel in isolation.
Checklist: marketplace and DTC strategy
- [ ] Each product group assigned a channel role
- [ ] Marketplace prices account for all fees
- [ ] Reasons to buy direct beyond price defined and communicated
- [ ] Exclusive bundles or products reserved for your own store
- [ ] Contribution per order calculated for each channel
- [ ] Customer lifetime value compared across channels where possible
- [ ] Cannibalization monitored after marketplace changes
- [ ] Inventory allocation planned across channels
- [ ] Marketplace policies on pricing and inserts checked
- [ ] Channel strategy reviewed at least twice a year
FAQ
Should a DTC brand sell on Amazon?
It depends on your category and goals. Marketplaces can bring large amounts of search demand and trust, but fees are high and customer data is limited. Many brands use marketplaces for discovery while building loyalty through their own store.
Will selling on a marketplace hurt my own store’s sales?
It can, if existing customers move to the marketplace. Monitor own-store and total sales after launch, and give customers reasons to buy direct.
How do I compare profitability across channels?
Use contribution per order after all fees, fulfillment, returns and marketing, and add customer lifetime value where you can measure it. Revenue alone hides big differences.