- Since February 2024, Gmail and Yahoo require bulk senders to authenticate with SPF and DKIM, publish a DMARC record, support one-click unsubscribe and keep spam complaints below 0.3%. Gmail has tightened enforcement since November 2025, including rejecting non-compliant mail.
- On Shopify, authenticate the sender domain for store notifications and Shopify Email, and set up a branded sending domain in your ESP. Without it, your sender address can be rewritten or shown "via" another domain.
- Authentication gets you through the door. Reputation keeps you in the inbox: send to people who engage, make leaving easy, and stop mailing people who have gone quiet.
What is email deliverability, and why is it different from delivery?
Your ESP reports an email as delivered when the receiving server accepts it. Email deliverability is whether it then lands in the inbox, the promotions tab or spam. A message can be 99% delivered and still mostly unseen.
Mailbox providers decide placement from three groups of signals:
- Identity: Can they verify the mail really comes from your domain?
- Reputation: How has mail from your domain and sending IPs performed over time?
- Engagement: Do recipients open, click, reply, delete without reading, or mark it as spam?
For a Shopify store, the cost is quiet: flows keep running while revenue per recipient slowly declines because fewer people see anything.
What do Gmail and Yahoo require from bulk senders?
In February 2024, Google and Yahoo began enforcing new sender requirements. Gmail defines a bulk sender as anyone who sends close to 5,000 or more messages to personal Gmail accounts within 24 hours. Mail from the same primary domain counts together, so order confirmations and shipping notices add to your marketing volume. Once you cross that line, Google treats you as a bulk sender permanently.
| Requirement | Gmail (bulk senders) | Yahoo (bulk senders) |
|---|---|---|
| Authentication | SPF and DKIM | SPF and DKIM |
| DMARC | Record required, minimum policy p=none | Valid policy, at least p=none, and DMARC must pass |
| Alignment | From domain aligned with the SPF or DKIM domain | From domain aligned with the SPF or DKIM domain (relaxed alignment accepted) |
| Unsubscribe | One-click unsubscribe (RFC 8058 headers) for marketing and subscribed messages, plus a visible unsubscribe link in the body | One-click unsubscribe via the List-Unsubscribe header for marketing and subscribed messages |
| Honoring unsubscribes | Within 48 hours | Within 2 days |
| Spam rate | Below 0.30% in Postmaster Tools; Google advises staying below 0.10% | Below 0.3% |
| Other | Valid forward and reverse DNS (PTR), TLS, messages formatted to RFC 5322 |
Smaller senders are not exempt from everything. Both providers expect at least SPF or DKIM and a spam rate under 0.3% from all senders, and Gmail also expects PTR records, TLS and standard formatting from everyone.
Transactional messages such as order confirmations don’t need one-click unsubscribe under Gmail’s rules, but they still count toward the volume threshold. Google has also said that from November 2025 it is ramping up enforcement on non-compliant traffic, which can mean temporary or permanent rejection rather than just spam placement.
Your ESP handles most of the technical side once your domain is set up. DNS records, list quality and complaint rates stay with you.
How do you authenticate email for a Shopify store?
Three DNS records do the work. Email authentication proves to mailbox providers that a message sent in your name really came from a service you authorized.
| Record | What it proves | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| SPF | The sending server is allowed to send for the domain | Provided by Shopify, your ESP and other senders; often set through CNAME records |
| DKIM | The message was signed by the domain and not altered | Keys provided by each sending service |
| DMARC | What receivers should do when SPF or DKIM fail to align with your From domain, and where to send reports | A TXT record at _dmarc.yourdomain.com that you publish |
Most Shopify stores send email from at least two places: Shopify itself (order notifications and Shopify Email) and an email service provider such as Klaviyo. Each needs its own setup.
Shopify notifications and Shopify Email
In the Shopify admin, authenticate the sender email domain you use for notifications. Shopify gives you CNAME records that configure DKIM and SPF, and requires a DMARC record of at least v=DMARC1; p=none. If the domain isn’t authenticated, Shopify rewrites your sender address to a shopifyemail.com address, which looks less trustworthy to customers. Domains bought through Shopify are configured automatically.
Klaviyo or another ESP
Most Klaviyo accounts start on a shared sending domain, so recipients may see “via klaviyomail.com” next to your name. A branded sending domain fixes that. You set it up on a subdomain, commonly something like send.yourdomain.com, by adding the DNS records Klaviyo provides. Other ESPs use similar steps under names like “domain authentication” or “custom sending domain.”
Getting DMARC right
Your domain can only have one DMARC record. Multiple DMARC records cause validation to fail, which is a common mistake when two tools each tell you to “add a DMARC record.”
Start with p=none and a reporting address (the rua tag) so you receive reports on who sends as your domain. After a few weeks you will usually find senders you forgot, such as Google Workspace, your helpdesk, a reviews app or an invoicing tool. Authenticate each one. Once all legitimate mail passes, you can consider moving to p=quarantine and later p=reject, which protects your domain from spoofing. Move slowly, because a stricter policy also blocks your own misconfigured senders.
How does list hygiene protect your sender reputation?
Authentication proves who you are. Your list decides how mailbox providers rate you. Sending regularly to people who never engage tells providers that your mail is unwanted.
Define engagement with reliable signals
Apple Mail Privacy Protection can register opens that never happened, so opens alone overstate engagement. Combine signals: clicks, site visits tracked by your ESP, orders and, where useful, opens from non-Apple clients.
Send more to engaged people, less to the rest
A tiered approach keeps volume where it performs. The windows below are illustrative; set yours based on your purchase cycle.
| Tier | Example definition | Campaign frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Engaged | Clicked, visited or ordered in the last 30 to 60 days | Full schedule |
| Warm | Engaged in the last 60 to 180 days | Reduced, best campaigns only |
| Unengaged | No engagement in 180+ days | Re-engagement sequence only |
| Sunset | Didn’t respond to re-engagement | Suppressed from marketing email |
Flows triggered by behavior, such as abandoned cart, can still reach people in lower tiers, because the trigger itself is a sign of engagement.
Keep bad addresses out
- Never import purchased or scraped lists, or old lists from years ago.
- Protect signup forms from bots; a sudden spike in signups with no clicks is a warning sign.
- Let your ESP suppress hard bounces automatically, and review repeated soft bounces.
- Remove role addresses like info@ or sales@ from marketing segments if they never engage.
- Make sure SMS-only and transactional-only contacts aren’t added to marketing email.
A clear welcome series also helps. Subscribers who know what to expect are less likely to report you as spam later. For the re-engagement step before sunsetting, see our win-back playbook.
How do you keep spam complaints under the threshold?
Both providers measure complaints against mail that reached the inbox, so small numbers matter.
Worked example (illustrative)
These numbers are for illustration only. Say a campaign reaches 100,000 Gmail inboxes. At 0.1%, 100 people clicking “Report spam” puts you at Google’s recommended ceiling. At 0.3%, 300 people do, and you have reached the line Google says to never hit. One badly targeted send to an old segment can do that.
Ways to keep complaints low:
- Make leaving easier than complaining. Keep the unsubscribe link visible in the footer, not hidden in light gray text.
- Offer a down option. A preference page that lets people choose fewer emails keeps some who would otherwise unsubscribe or complain.
- Keep the sender name consistent so people recognize you.
- Match frequency to what you promised at signup.
- Never restart a dormant segment at full volume. Warm it up with your best content first.
How do you monitor deliverability?
- Google Postmaster Tools: Verify your domain to see the user-reported spam rate and authentication results for mail to Gmail users.
- ESP reports by mailbox provider: Compare open, click, bounce and complaint rates for Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook and Apple. A sudden drop at one provider points to a placement problem there.
- DMARC reports: Use a report reader to spot new or failing senders.
- Revenue per recipient: If it falls while list size grows, check deliverability before rewriting creative.
The Email Revenue Calculator gives you a benchmark for what your list should produce, so a deliverability problem shows up as a gap you can size.
What should your deliverability checklist include?
- [ ] Shopify sender domain authenticated, with no rewritten shopifyemail.com sender.
- [ ] Branded sending domain live in your ESP; no “via” label in Gmail.
- [ ] One DMARC record at p=none or stricter, with reports going to an inbox or tool someone reads.
- [ ] Every other service sending as your domain identified and authenticated.
- [ ] One-click unsubscribe working on marketing email, plus a visible footer link.
- [ ] Engagement tiers and a sunset rule in place, based on clicks, visits and orders.
- [ ] Google Postmaster Tools set up and spam rate checked weekly.
- [ ] Bot protection on signup forms.
FAQ
Do the Gmail and Yahoo rules apply to small Shopify stores?
The strictest rules apply to bulk senders, which Gmail defines as close to 5,000 or more messages a day to personal Gmail accounts. Basic rules, such as SPF or DKIM and a spam rate under 0.3%, apply to everyone. Since most ESPs now make authentication part of setup, it is simpler to meet the full set from the start.
Is a DMARC policy of p=none enough?
It meets the minimum Gmail and Yahoo require for bulk senders. It doesn’t protect your domain from spoofing, though, so plan to move toward quarantine or reject once reports show all legitimate senders pass.
Do order confirmations need a one-click unsubscribe?
Under Gmail’s rules, transactional messages are exempt from the one-click unsubscribe requirement, but they still count toward the bulk sender volume. Keep promotional content in them light, so they stay clearly transactional.