Commerce Advisory · Operating Model & Tooling

eCommerce Operating Model & Martech Stack Audit

Clear owners for every number that matters, a tool stack you can explain line by line, and a weekly and monthly rhythm that turns the roadmap into finished work.

  • Clear ownership
  • A leaner stack
  • KPI framework and cadence

Why plans stall

Most growth plans fail on ownership, not strategy

A typical DTC brand at this size has a small in-house team, two or three agencies, a few freelancers and dozens of apps. Each agency reports its own channel in its own dashboard. Nobody owns the second order, because it sits between paid media, email and the product team. The stack grows one app at a time, and nobody knows what it costs in total.

Operating Model & Tooling, part of our Commerce Advisory service, fixes the layer underneath the plan: who decides, who does the work, which tools stay and how progress gets reviewed.

Who owns what

An ownership map that puts a name next to every profit lever

AreaOwns the numberContributesKPI they answer for
Contribution margin after marketingFounder or GMFinance, eCommerce leadMonthly contribution margin
New customer acquisitionPaid media leadCreative, CRO, SEONew customer CAC, POAS
The second orderRetention leadProduct, support, paid mediaFirst-to-second order rate
Site conversioneCommerce leadDesign, development, CROConversion rate by device
Data and consentAnalytics ownerDevelopment, legal counselTracking match rate against orders

Example roles. In small teams one person often holds several rows; the point is that no row is empty.

The martech stack audit

Every tool justified, consolidated or cut

  1. Inventory

    List every tool and app

    Monthly cost, contract dates, owner, how often it's used and what data it touches. Apps installed for a single campaign show up here.

  2. Overlap

    Find the duplicates

    Two review apps, three popups, several tools sending the same purchase event. Overlap costs money and corrupts data.

  3. Privacy

    Check what each tool collects

    Which pixels and scripts load, what customer data each vendor receives and whether a DPA is in place. Confirm legal requirements with counsel.

  4. Decide

    Keep, consolidate or cut

    A recommendation per tool, with the saving, the migration effort and the risk. Removal comes before anything new is added.

  5. Sunset

    Plan the switch-offs

    An order of removal, data exports, flow and tracking checks, and a date each tool is turned off.

The KPI framework

One profit number at the top, and drivers everyone understands

A KPI framework decides which numbers each meeting looks at, so a weekly call doesn't turn into a tour of five dashboards. We build ours in three levels.

Level 1: the business

Contribution margin after marketing, reviewed monthly. This is the number the roadmap is designed to grow.

Level 2: the drivers

  • New customers and new customer CAC
  • First-to-second order rate and days to second order
  • Cohort LTV by acquisition month and channel
  • AOV and contribution margin per order

Level 3: channel diagnostics

POAS for paid media, revenue per subscriber for email and SMS, conversion rate by device and template, and organic revenue by landing page. Channel teams manage to these, and each one ties back to a driver above it. Try the POAS Calculator to see how the acquisition number is built.

Meeting cadence

A rhythm that fits a small team and a time zone gap

Too many meetings slow a lean team down. Too few let the plan drift. We set three, each with a fixed agenda and owner, and run our side of them in the overlap with U.S. Eastern mornings. Updates in between happen async.

  • Weekly: a short growth stand-up on Level 2 drivers, blockers and the coming week's launches
  • Monthly: a roadmap review on Level 1 and 2, re-ranking initiatives and cutting what missed its KPI
  • Quarterly: planning for the next 90 days, budget shifts and stack decisions

FAQ

Operating model and martech audit questions

What is an eCommerce operating model?

An eCommerce operating model describes how the online business actually runs: who owns which results, which work stays in-house and which goes to agencies or freelancers, which tools support it and how decisions get made and reviewed. It turns strategy into a weekly routine. Without one, even a good roadmap waits on whoever has spare time.

What does a martech stack audit include?

A full inventory of tools and apps with cost, owner, usage and the customer data each one touches, a review of overlaps and duplicate tracking, a privacy check on what each vendor receives, and a keep, consolidate or cut recommendation per tool. You also get a switch-off plan, so removing a tool doesn't break a flow, a report or a pixel.

Which tools do you usually recommend?

Whatever fits your platform, team and budget, after we've removed what you don't need. On Shopify, retention stacks often center on Klaviyo plus an SMS, reviews and subscription tool. Our Stack Reviews explain who each tool suits. Some links there are affiliate links, and that never changes our recommendation.

How do you handle change management?

New owners, meetings and tools only stick if the team is part of the change. We agree the ownership map with the people named in it, train them on new tools, rewrite the SOPs that change and review adoption after the first month. Our glossary entry on change management covers the basics.

Can you run the operating model with us?

Yes. Many brands keep us as part of the weekly and monthly cadence, with a dedicated strategist who owns the roadmap review and reports on revenue, margin and LTV. Others run the cadence in-house after setup. Retainers are scoped after the Free Profit Audit or a discovery call.

Put a name, a number and a meeting behind every priority

Start with the free audit to see where profit is leaking, or book a call to talk through how your team and stack are set up today.

Free Profit Audit