SMS Marketing

SMS List Growth: Pop-ups, Keywords and Checkout Opt-ins That Stay Compliant

Grow your SMS list with pop-ups, tap-to-text, keywords and checkout opt-ins, keep a clean consent record for each source and judge growth by subscriber value.

TL;DR
  • Every SMS subscriber needs a recorded, affirmative opt-in with the disclosure shown at that moment. Build each growth source (pop-up, tap-to-text, keyword, checkout, post-purchase) so it produces that record automatically.
  • The best sources are not the biggest ones. Track opt-out rate and revenue per subscriber by source, because a cheap source full of discount hunters can cost more than it earns.
  • Size the signup incentive against what a subscriber is worth to you after message costs, not against what competitors offer. This guide covers practical basics; confirm your opt-in flows with counsel.

Why does the source of an SMS subscriber matter?

A subscriber who texted a keyword from your packaging after a second order is a different asset from one who typed a number into a pop-up for 20% off. Both count as list growth. Only one is likely to buy again at full price.

Source also decides how strong your consent record is. Under the TCPA, marketing texts need prior express written consent, and if a claim arrives you need to show who agreed, when and what they saw. Our SMS compliance guide covers the rules; this playbook is about building each source so it grows the list and keeps the record.

Source Shopper intent Consent evidence it can produce Main risk
Website pop-up (two-step) Browsing, often first visit Form submission, timestamp, page URL, disclosure version Discount-driven signups who never buy at full price
Tap-to-text on mobile Browsing, mobile Inbound text from the subscriber’s own phone Disclosure must still be visible on the form
Keyword (text JOIN) Varies by placement Inbound text plus your confirmation reply Keyword shown without the disclosure next to it
Checkout checkbox Buying now Checkbox selection with the phone number Confusing marketing consent with delivery updates
Post-purchase page or email Just bought Form or keyword record Low volume if you only ask once

How do you set up an SMS pop-up that grows the list without hurting email?

The pop-up is usually the largest source, so small decisions here move the whole list.

Keep the two-step structure

Ask for email first and phone second, with the SMS disclosure under the phone field. Shoppers who skip the second step still join your email list. Our SMS marketing guide explains the setup; the point here is that the phone step should never block the email step.

Use tap-to-text on mobile

On a phone, typing a number is friction. With tap-to-text, the shopper taps a button, their messaging app opens with a prefilled message containing your keyword, and they send it. Klaviyo, for example, offers this on its sign-up forms and notes that the disclosure must still appear on the form and that it doesn’t work with branded sender IDs, which can’t receive texts.

Target the pop-up carefully

  • Don’t show the SMS step to existing SMS subscribers. Most form tools can suppress by profile property or list membership.
  • Delay it on landing pages from paid ads. A visitor who arrived on a product page from Meta should see the product first. A short delay or a scroll trigger usually works better than an instant overlay.
  • Use exit intent on desktop, a time or scroll trigger on mobile. Exit intent depends on cursor movement, which phones don’t have.

Put the disclosure where it is read

The disclosure belongs directly under the phone field or the tap-to-text button, in readable type. It should name your brand, say messages are recurring automated marketing texts, give frequency, say message and data rates may apply, explain STOP and HELP, state that consent is not a condition of purchase and link to your SMS terms and privacy policy. Save every version of this text with the dates it was live.

How do keyword opt-ins work, and where should you use them?

A keyword opt-in asks people to text a word, such as JOIN or VIP, to your number. Your platform replies with a confirmation that repeats the program details. Keywords suit places where a form can’t go:

  • Packaging and inserts. A card in the box reaches people who already bought.
  • Social profiles and posts. A keyword in a bio or story gives followers a way in without leaving the app.
  • Creator content. A unique keyword per creator shows which partnerships bring buyers.
  • Events and retail counters. A QR code that opens a prefilled text works like tap-to-text.

Two rules make keywords work. First, the call to action needs the disclosure next to it, even on a small insert; “Text JOIN to 12345” alone is not enough. Second, use a different keyword per placement so you can measure each one.

Checkout is where intent is highest, and it’s also where marketing consent is most often confused with operational contact.

On Shopify, the setting lives in the admin under Settings, then Checkout, then Marketing options, where you can turn on SMS. The phone number field has to be visible at checkout for the checkbox to appear, so check your SMS platform’s setup guide for the field setting it expects. Then connect the consent to your SMS tool. Klaviyo’s documentation, for example, says consent syncs once the shopper enters a phone number, ticks the box and continues to shipping, even if they don’t finish the order, and only for people who are not already SMS subscribers in Shopify.

On WooCommerce and Magento, you need your SMS platform’s extension or a custom field. Whatever you use, the checkbox must start unchecked and the disclosure must sit next to it.

Three points to get right on any platform:

  • Keep delivery numbers separate from marketing consent. A shopper who gives a number for the courier has not agreed to marketing texts.
  • Back the checkbox label with the full disclosure, in the label or in a text block next to it. Confirm the wording with counsel.
  • Check age-gated products. Klaviyo, for instance, notes that age-gated accounts can’t subscribe people through the Shopify checkbox and should use an age-gated form instead.

Should you use double opt-in for SMS?

Double opt-in means the subscriber replies to a confirmation text (for example, “Reply Y to confirm”) before marketing starts. It is not always a legal requirement, but it gives you the clearest consent record and removes mistyped numbers. Some platforms set their own rules: Klaviyo, for example, requires double opt-in for U.S. subscribers if you plan to send them abandoned cart texts.

Expect fewer confirmed subscribers than form submissions. The gap is mostly typos and people who only wanted to see the discount.

What incentive should you offer for SMS signups?

The incentive shapes the list. A large percentage discount fills the list fastest and teaches subscribers to wait for codes. Free shipping, early access, a gift with first order or a smaller fixed amount often hold margin better.

Size it with your own numbers:

  1. Estimate value per subscriber. Use revenue per subscriber over 90 or 180 days from your current list, multiplied by your contribution margin, minus message costs per subscriber.
  2. Estimate the incentive cost. Multiply the discount value by the share of new subscribers who redeem it. Count only the discount on orders that would have happened anyway as a pure cost; the rest bought a sale.
  3. Compare by source. A checkout opt-in needs no incentive at all, because the shopper is already buying.

Worked example: two pop-up offers

All numbers are illustrative.

A store tests two pop-up offers for a month each. Average first order is $80, contribution margin is 40%, and free shipping costs the store about $8 per order.

Offer New SMS subscribers Redeemed on first order Discount cost 90-day opt-out rate 90-day revenue per subscriber
20% off first order 2,000 900 $14,400 High $14
Free shipping on first order 1,400 500 $4,000 Lower $16

The 20% offer adds 600 more subscribers but costs $10,400 more in discounts. Its subscribers also leave faster and spend less per head over 90 days. At 40% margin, 2,000 subscribers at $14 earn $11,200 of contribution, under the $14,400 discount cost. The free shipping cohort earns $8,960 of contribution against $4,000. The smaller offer built the more profitable list.

How do you measure the quality of list growth?

Report growth by source every month, not just the total.

Metric How to calculate What it tells you
Opt-in rate New SMS subscribers ÷ people who saw the form or placement Whether the offer and placement work
Confirmation rate Confirmed subscribers ÷ form submissions (with double opt-in) How many signups were real
30-day opt-out rate Opt-outs in first 30 days ÷ new subscribers Whether the welcome texts match what was promised
90-day revenue per subscriber Revenue from the cohort ÷ cohort size Whether the source brings buyers
Net list growth New subscribers − opt-outs − suppressions Whether the list is actually growing

Tag every source with its own form, keyword or list property so these numbers come out of your platform without manual work, and apply regular list hygiene so numbers that never engage don’t sit on the list collecting cost and risk.

Checklist: compliant SMS growth sources

  • [ ] Every source (pop-up, tap-to-text, keyword, checkout, post-purchase) has the full disclosure visible at the point of opt-in.
  • [ ] Consent checkboxes start unchecked, and SMS consent is stored separately from email consent.
  • [ ] Each source has its own form ID, keyword or property so you can report by source.
  • [ ] The confirmation text goes out immediately and repeats brand, frequency, rates and STOP/HELP.
  • [ ] Double opt-in is on where your platform requires it or your counsel advises it.
  • [ ] Delivery phone numbers are never added to marketing lists without a separate opt-in.
  • [ ] Every disclosure version is saved with the dates it was live.
  • [ ] The SMS pop-up is suppressed for existing subscribers and delayed on paid landing pages.
  • [ ] Incentive cost is compared with 90-day contribution per subscriber, by source.
  • [ ] Counsel has reviewed each opt-in flow before launch.

FAQ

What is the fastest way to grow an SMS list?

A two-step pop-up with tap-to-text on mobile usually brings the most signups, and a checkout checkbox adds high-intent buyers at no incentive cost. Fast growth only helps if those subscribers buy, so compare sources on 90-day revenue per subscriber before scaling the offer.

Can I add customers who gave their phone number at checkout to my SMS list?

Not for marketing, unless they also opted in to marketing texts with the disclosure shown. A number given for delivery updates is not marketing consent. Confirm how you handle these numbers with counsel.

Do I need a different keyword for every placement?

It’s not required, but it’s the simplest way to see which placements bring buyers. One keyword per insert, creator or event keeps reporting clean, as long as each placement shows the disclosure next to it.

Turn this into a plan for your store

The Free Profit Audit scans your store, sizes your biggest profit leaks and builds a 90-day plan.

Free Profit Audit