SMS Marketing

SMS Marketing for U.S. eCommerce: Consent, Timing and the Flows Worth Sending

A hands-on guide to SMS marketing for U.S. eCommerce: consent basics, list growth, which flows to text, frequency and message cost versus revenue.

TL;DR
  • U.S. marketing texts need clear prior consent (in practice, prior express written consent), honest disclosures at signup, working STOP and HELP replies, sensible send times and a registered sending number. Confirm your setup with counsel.
  • Grow the list with a two-step signup form (email first, phone second) and a consent checkbox at checkout. Use SMS for high-intent, time-sensitive moments such as checkout abandonment, back in stock and launches for engaged buyers.
  • Judge SMS by revenue per subscriber after message costs, not by clicks. Every text costs money, so it has to earn more than the email it adds to or replaces.

This section explains common practice, not legal advice. Rules change and vary by state, so confirm your program with counsel before you launch.

The main federal law is the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). For automated marketing texts, the standard the industry works to is prior express written consent: a clear, affirmative action by the subscriber after they see what they’re agreeing to. That action can be checking an unchecked box, submitting a phone number in a form with the disclosure next to it, or texting a keyword to your number.

Here is what most compliant programs include:

  • [ ] Clear disclosure at signup: your brand name, that messages are recurring automated marketing texts, that consent is not a condition of purchase, expected message frequency, “Msg & data rates may apply,” how to opt out and links to your SMS terms and privacy policy.
  • [ ] Double opt-in: a confirmation text the subscriber replies to (for example, “Reply Y to confirm”). Not every program requires it, but it’s common practice because it creates a clean consent record and filters out typos.
  • [ ] STOP and HELP: opt-outs honored right away, including common words like “cancel,” “unsubscribe,” “end” and “quit.” HELP returns your brand name and a support contact. Every major SMS platform handles these automatically; test them anyway.
  • [ ] Quiet hours: federal TCPA rules restrict telephone solicitations before 8 a.m. and after 9 p.m. in the recipient’s local time, and some states set narrower windows or frequency limits. Set your platform’s quiet hours conservatively, based on the subscriber’s location.
  • [ ] Carrier registration: texts from a standard 10-digit number need 10DLC brand and campaign registration through The Campaign Registry. Toll-free numbers need toll-free verification, and short codes go through their own carrier approval. Your platform usually manages this; unregistered traffic gets filtered or blocked.
  • [ ] Consent records: timestamp, source (form, checkout, keyword), the exact wording shown and the phone number, stored where you can retrieve them.

Two mistakes to avoid. First, a phone number collected for shipping is not marketing consent. Don’t text order phone numbers unless that customer also opted in to SMS marketing. Second, your consent management platform (the cookie banner) handles tracking consent on your site. It does not capture SMS consent.

How do you grow an SMS list without hurting your email list?

The most common setup is a two-step signup form. Step one asks for the email address in exchange for the offer. Step two asks for the phone number, with the SMS disclosure beneath the field. People who skip step two still join your email list, so SMS growth doesn’t cost you email signups. Klaviyo, Attentive and Postscript all support multi-step forms.

Other good sources:

  • Checkout. On Shopify, you can enable an SMS marketing checkbox at checkout and sync that consent to your SMS tool. On WooCommerce and Magento you’ll need a plugin, extension or custom field, plus the same disclosure text.
  • Keyword opt-in. “Text JOIN to 12345” on packaging, inserts, social posts or a retail counter.
  • Post-purchase. The order confirmation page and the first shipping email are good places to invite buyers who skipped the checkbox.

Be careful with the signup incentive. A steep discount for joining SMS trains subscribers to expect deals by text. Free shipping, early access to launches or a smaller first-order offer often hold margin better. Deliver the code instantly in the confirmation text, which also opens your welcome series.

Never buy or rent phone lists, never pre-check the consent box and never add numbers from a contest or survey unless the disclosure was shown there.

Which flows should you send by SMS, and which by email?

SMS is interruptive and costs money per message. Email is cheap and can carry more content. A good rule: text when timing changes the outcome. Each of these is a triggered email flow first, with SMS added where it earns its place.

Flow SMS? Email? Why
Welcome 1 text: confirm and deliver the code Full series The code arrives where they signed up
Checkout abandonment Yes, 1 text within a few hours Yes Highest purchase intent
Cart abandonment Selectively, for larger carts Yes Medium intent; cost has to pay back
Browse abandonment Usually no Yes Intent too low for the cost
Back in stock, price drop Yes Yes Time-sensitive; stock runs out
Post-purchase cross-sell Selectively Yes Email carries product detail better
Winback 1 text for high-value lapsed buyers Yes Worth the cost only for valuable customers
Campaigns and launches Engaged segments only Yes Protects opt-out rate and budget

Order and shipping updates by text are useful, but transactional and marketing messages are handled differently. Check how your platform separates them and what consent each needs.

An SMS campaign (a one-off send, as opposed to a flow) should go to an engaged segment, not the whole list. Define “engaged” with data: clicked or purchased in the last 60 to 90 days, for example. This is basic audience segmentation, and it matters more for SMS than for email because every send costs money.

How often should you text, and when?

There’s no universal right frequency. A common starting point is your flows plus a few campaigns a month to engaged subscribers, then adjust based on opt-out rate and revenue per send. Whatever you choose, it should match the frequency you disclosed at signup.

Practical timing rules:

  • Send in the subscriber’s local time, inside your quiet-hours window. Most platforms can hold a flow text until the window opens.
  • Suppress recent purchasers from promotional sends for a few days.
  • Don’t send an email and a text with the same offer at the same moment. Stagger them, or send SMS only to people who didn’t open the email.

Message length and cost

SMS is billed by segment. One segment holds 160 standard (GSM-7) characters. If the message contains any character outside that set, including most emoji, the limit drops to 70. Longer messages split into multiple segments, and each is billed. MMS (texts with images) usually costs more per message. Start every text with your brand name, keep it to one segment where you can and use a branded short link.

Does SMS make money after message costs?

Run the math per send. Here is a worked example with illustrative numbers. Use your own platform’s pricing.

A store has 20,000 SMS subscribers. Each text is two segments, at an illustrative $0.015 per segment. Average order value is $70 and contribution margin is 40%.

Scenario Recipients Message cost Orders Revenue Contribution after cost
Send to engaged segment 12,000 $360 60 $4,200 $1,320
Send to full list 20,000 $600 66 $4,620 $1,248

Sending to the full list costs $240 more, brings 6 more orders and leaves less contribution. It also raises opt-outs among people who weren’t going to buy. Each lost subscriber is lost future revenue.

The other number to watch is revenue per subscriber:

Revenue per subscriber = SMS revenue in a period ÷ average number of SMS subscribers in that period

If SMS brings in $9,000 in a month across 20,000 subscribers, that’s $0.45 per subscriber. If messages cost $0.12 per subscriber that month, your contribution margin has to be above about 27% (0.12 ÷ 0.45) just to cover sending costs. Put your own figures into the Revenue per Subscriber Calculator to see what a subscriber is worth and what you can afford to pay to acquire one.

How do you measure SMS performance?

Track these per flow and per campaign:

  • Revenue per recipient and revenue per subscriber, after message costs.
  • Opt-out rate per send. A rising rate means frequency or targeting is off.
  • Cost per message, including MMS and any carrier fees your platform passes through.
  • Incrementality. Hold out a random share of each flow’s SMS-eligible entrants from the text, and compare their purchase rate with the group that got it.
  • Net list growth: new subscribers minus opt-outs.

Attribution is the hard part. SMS and email often get credit for the same order. Tag every link with UTM parameters so GA4 shows SMS as its own channel, and reconcile platform-reported revenue with Shopify orders.

Klaviyo SMS, Attentive or Postscript?

All three handle consent capture, STOP/HELP, quiet hours and carrier registration. The differences are about fit:

  • Klaviyo SMS keeps email and SMS on one profile with one segmentation engine. It’s the simplest choice if Klaviyo already runs your email.
  • Attentive is an SMS-first platform with a broad feature set and managed services. It works across several eCommerce platforms.
  • Postscript is SMS-focused and built for Shopify.

Compare per-message pricing for SMS and MMS, platform fees, and how cleanly each syncs consent and orders with your store. WooCommerce and Magento stores should confirm current integrations before choosing. If you want help building the program, our Lifecycle Retention team sets up consent, flows and measurement end to end.

FAQ

Do I need double opt-in for SMS in the U.S.?

It’s not always required, but it’s common practice. A confirmation reply gives you a clear consent record and removes mistyped numbers. Ask counsel what your program needs.

Can I text customers who gave their phone number at checkout?

Only if they also opted in to SMS marketing, for example by checking the SMS consent box with the disclosure shown. A phone number collected for shipping or delivery updates is not marketing consent.

How many marketing texts should I send per month?

There’s no universal number. Start with your core flows and a few campaigns to engaged subscribers, stay within the frequency you disclosed, and adjust based on opt-out rate and revenue per send.

Turn this into a plan for your store

The Free Profit Audit scans your store, sizes your biggest profit leaks and builds a 90-day plan.

Free Profit Audit