Email Marketing

Email Sign-Up Pop-ups: Timing, Offers and Mobile Rules That Grow Your List

How to set email pop-up timing, choose an offer that protects margin, follow Google's mobile guidance and measure whether new subscribers actually buy.

TL;DR
  • A pop-up should grow a list of people who will buy, not just collect addresses. Judge it on revenue and margin per new subscriber, not on submit rate alone.
  • Show it after a signal of interest (time, scroll depth, page views or exit intent), and on mobile follow Google's guidance: no full-screen overlays that hide content, small and easy-to-close formats instead.
  • Pick the offer by margin, not habit. Collect email first, then SMS on a second step with its own consent language.

What should an email pop-up actually do?

An email sign-up pop-up has one job: turn anonymous visitors into subscribers you can market to through your welcome series and later flows. Most stores already have one. The usual problem is not whether it exists, but that it was set up once with a default discount, default timing and no measurement beyond “submit rate.”

Submit rate is easy to inflate. Show the form instantly, offer a big discount and many visitors will hand over an email to get the code. Some of them were going to buy anyway, and now they pay less. Others enter an address they never check. A better target is revenue per new subscriber over 30 and 90 days, net of the discount you gave.

When should the pop-up appear?

Timing decides who sees the form and how annoying it feels. Klaviyo’s sign-up forms, for example, can display immediately or based on rules: a time delay, scroll depth, a number of page views or exit intent. Klaviyo says it detects exit intent when the cursor leaves the visible page on desktop, or when a visitor scrolls quickly upward on mobile. You can require all selected rules to be met, or let any one of them trigger the form.

Trigger Best for Main risk
Immediately on landing Rarely the right choice Interrupts before the visitor sees anything; weak on mobile
Time delay Content and product pages where people read Many visitors leave a page within seconds and never see it
Scroll depth Long product or blog pages Fires late on short pages
Page views (for example, 2 or 3) Catching engaged browsers Misses one-page visitors from ads
Exit intent A last offer before leaving Mobile detection is less precise than desktop
Custom trigger (button or link) “Get 10% off” tab, quiz entry points Only reaches people who click

In our experience, a short delay combined with a second page view, plus an exit-intent pop-up as a backup, is a sensible starting point. Then test against your own data.

Frequency and suppression

Decide what happens after someone closes or submits the form. Klaviyo lets you set how many days pass before a closed form reappears, and you can stop it from showing again after a submission. Those settings rely on browser storage, so they reset if cookies are cleared. Also suppress the form for known subscribers arriving from your own emails and texts. Asking a subscriber to subscribe is a wasted impression.

What does Google say about pop-ups on mobile?

Google’s Search Central documentation, under page experience, has a page called “Avoid intrusive interstitials and dialogs.” It describes intrusive interstitials and dialogs as page elements that obstruct users’ view of the content, usually for promotional purposes. Interstitials cover the whole page; dialogs cover part of it.

Google’s guidance, in short:

  • Do not cover the entire page with an interstitial.
  • Use banners that take up only a small fraction of the screen instead. Google notes these can be used for newsletter sign-ups.
  • Interstitials required by law, such as an age gate, are exempt, although Google still recommends overlaying content rather than redirecting to a separate page.

Google says intrusive dialogs may lead to poor search performance and make a site less likely to be revisited. It does not give a pixel or percentage limit, so use judgment.

In practice, for mobile:

  • Use a bottom banner, slide-in or small teaser tab that leaves the product visible.
  • Do not open a full-screen overlay the moment a visitor arrives from search.
  • Make the close button large and obvious.
  • If you show a larger form, show it after a click on the teaser or after real engagement, not on page load.

Pop-up scripts also add weight to the page. Load them after the main content so they do not hurt your Core Web Vitals.

Which offer should you lead with?

The offer is the biggest lever on both sign-up volume and cost. Choose it with your margins in front of you.

Percentage discount. The most common choice and the most expensive on high-ticket orders. A 15% code on a $200 order costs $30 of margin. It works best for low-to-mid price products with healthy contribution margin.

Fixed-amount discount. “$10 off your first order over $60” caps the cost and nudges basket size. It is easier to model than a percentage.

Free shipping. Often cheaper than a discount for heavy-margin, light products. Pair it with your free shipping threshold so it does not undercut it.

Gift with purchase. A sample or accessory with a low cost to you can feel more valuable than a discount and does not anchor shoppers to a lower price.

No discount at all. Early access, restock alerts, a buying guide or a product quiz. Volume is usually lower, but subscribers join because they want your products. A quiz also captures zero-party data you can segment on, as our guide to product quizzes explains.

Whatever you offer, use unique, single-use codes where your platform supports them, so codes do not end up on coupon sites. And make sure the code is delivered and reminded inside the welcome email series, where most of its value is realized.

Copy that converts without hype

State the offer in the headline, say what subscribers get after it (“New arrivals and restocks, about twice a month”), and keep fields to the minimum. A short line of social proof, such as a review count, can help if it is true and current.

How should you add SMS to the pop-up?

The common pattern is a two-step form: email on the first step, phone number on the second. Asking for both at once usually lowers completion, and SMS needs its own consent anyway.

Klaviyo’s guide to collecting SMS consent states that:

  • Consent must be explicit, and disclosure language should sit above the SMS consent checkbox or button.
  • Consent cannot be required, or appear to be required, to make a purchase.
  • A separate checkbox or button should be used for SMS; a general “agree to marketing” option is not enough.

These rules exist because of the TCPA and carrier requirements. Have your disclosure reviewed by counsel. For the full playbook on growing the SMS side, see our guide to SMS list growth.

How do you know if your pop-up pays?

Track these numbers by device and by offer:

  • Form views and submit rate.
  • Share of new subscribers who place a first order within 30 days.
  • Revenue and contribution margin per new subscriber at 30 and 90 days, after discount cost.
  • Discount redemptions from people who were already in checkout or returning customers.
  • Bounce rate and conversion rate of sessions that saw the form, compared with similar sessions that did not.

Worked example: comparing two offers (illustrative numbers)

All numbers below are illustrative.

A store with a $70 average first order and a 50% contribution margin before discounts tests two pop-up offers for four weeks, each shown to 50,000 visitors.

Metric 15% off Free shipping
Submit rate 4.0% 3.0%
New subscribers 2,000 1,500
First orders within 30 days 300 240
Discount or shipping cost per order $10.50 $7.00
Contribution per first order $24.50 $28.00
Total contribution from first orders $7,350 $6,720
Contribution per new subscriber $3.68 $4.48

The 15% offer wins on volume and total first-order contribution. Free shipping earns more per subscriber. The deciding question is the 90-day view: if the free-shipping group repeats at a similar rate without expecting codes, it may win over time. Run the comparison long enough to see repeat orders before you switch for good. Our revenue per subscriber calculator helps you set the baseline.

Email pop-up checklist

  • [ ] Define success as revenue and margin per new subscriber, not submit rate.
  • [ ] Use a delay, scroll depth or page-view rule instead of showing on landing.
  • [ ] Add an exit-intent version as a backup.
  • [ ] On mobile, use a banner, slide-in or teaser that leaves content visible.
  • [ ] Make the close control large and easy to find.
  • [ ] Suppress the form for existing subscribers and recent submitters.
  • [ ] Model the offer’s cost per order against contribution margin.
  • [ ] Use unique, single-use codes where possible.
  • [ ] Collect email first, then phone number on a second step with separate SMS consent.
  • [ ] Load the pop-up script after main content.
  • [ ] Review results by device and offer every month.

FAQ

Will a pop-up hurt our SEO?

It can if it blocks content on mobile, especially right after a visitor arrives. Google’s guidance discourages interstitials that cover the page and recommends small banners instead. Legally required interstitials, such as age gates, are exempt. Keep mobile forms small, delayed and easy to close.

Should every visitor see the same pop-up?

No. Visitors from email and SMS are usually already subscribed, so hide it for them. Returning customers may respond better to a restock alert or loyalty message than to a first-order discount. Many stores also run different forms for desktop and mobile.

Is a spin-to-win wheel a good idea?

It can lift submit rate, but it often gives away larger discounts than needed and can feel off-brand. If you test one, cap the prizes at offers your margins can afford, and judge it on margin per subscriber over 90 days, like any other offer.

Turn this into a plan for your store

The Free Profit Audit scans your store, sizes your biggest profit leaks and builds a 90-day plan.

Free Profit Audit