- Treat email as the default channel and make SMS something a message earns, through high intent, high customer value or real time sensitivity.
- Sequence the two channels instead of duplicating them: send the email first, then text only the people who didn't act, and exit everyone the moment they buy.
- Set a frequency cap across both channels yourself, then measure the SMS layer with a holdout group, because both channels will claim credit for the same orders.
Why does adding SMS often add cost instead of revenue?
Most stores add SMS by bolting a text onto each email flow. SMS-attributed revenue appears overnight, but look closer and three problems usually show up.
- The same message twice. A customer gets “Your cart is waiting” by email at 2:00 p.m. and the same words by text at 2:05 p.m. One of those messages did the work, and you paid for both.
- Double-counted revenue. Your email platform credits the order to the email, the SMS tool credits it to the text, and both count it within their attribution windows. Add them up and you’ll report more revenue than the store actually took.
- Opt-outs from over-messaging. A text is more interruptive than an email. Customers who feel bombarded unsubscribe from SMS first, and you lose the channel for the moments that matter.
The fix isn’t less SMS. It’s clear rules for who gets which message and in what order. For consent, list growth and per-flow SMS decisions, see our guide to SMS marketing for eCommerce.
Which channels can each subscriber receive?
Start by splitting your audience by channel status. Every rule that follows depends on it.
| Subscriber status | What you can send | Default approach |
|---|---|---|
| Email only | Full program by email; invite to SMS at high-intent moments | |
| SMS only | SMS | Shorter flows; ask for an email address in the first text or on the thank-you page |
| Both | Email and SMS | Email first, SMS as a follow-up or for time-sensitive and high-value moments |
| Neither (customer, no marketing consent) | Transactional messages only | Order and shipping updates; invite to subscribe on the thank-you page |
Email and SMS consent are separate. A customer who agreed to email hasn’t agreed to texts, and the rules for SMS consent in the U.S. are stricter. Store each consent with its source and timestamp, and confirm your setup with counsel.
The “both” group is usually your most engaged audience, and it’s where duplication does the most damage.
What are the routing rules for email and SMS?
These five rules cover most situations. Write them down so everyone building flows and campaigns uses the same logic.
Rule 1: Email is the default; SMS has to earn its place
Every message starts as email. Add an SMS step only when at least one of these is true:
- Intent is high. The customer started checkout or asked to be told when an item is back in stock.
- Value is high. The customer is in a top value segment, so the cost of a text is small against what they spend.
- Timing changes the outcome. Limited stock, a sale ending tonight, a delivery problem.
In practice, this is audience segmentation applied to channel choice. Our Value × Intent (RFMB) model makes it concrete. A high-value customer at Buying Stage B4 (checkout started in the last 30 days) earns a text. A first-time visitor at B2 (viewed a product) gets email only.
Rule 2: Sequence, don’t duplicate
When both channels are justified, send the email first. After a set wait, text only the people who haven’t clicked, visited or bought.
Use clicks and site activity as the condition, not opens. Apple Mail Privacy Protection can register opens that never happened, so “didn’t open” is an unreliable filter.
Rule 3: Purchase exits everything
A purchase on any channel should remove the customer from every abandonment and promotional flow, on both email and SMS. If your SMS tool and ESP are separate products, check how fast an order reaches each. A text sent after the order is placed is the most expensive mistake in this playbook.
Rule 4: Cap frequency across channels
Don’t assume your platform does this. In Klaviyo, for example, Smart Sending skips a message if the profile recently received another one on the same channel. The default windows are 16 hours for email and 24 hours for SMS, but each channel is managed independently, so an email doesn’t stop a text on the same day. Add your own cross-channel rule, such as a flow filter or conditional split that holds a promotional text if the customer received a campaign email earlier that day.
Rule 5: Transactional stays transactional
Order confirmations and shipping updates by text are useful, and customers expect them. Keep promotional content out of them, and check how your platform separates transactional and marketing messages and what consent each needs.
How should each flow split between email and SMS?
Here’s how the rules translate into the core flows. The SMS column assumes the customer is subscribed to both channels.
| Flow | SMS step | SMS condition | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Welcome | Full series | One text to deliver the signup offer | Signed up via an SMS form |
| Checkout abandonment | 2 to 3 emails | One text after the first email | No click or purchase since the email |
| Cart abandonment | 2 emails | Optional | High-value segment or cart above a set amount |
| Browse abandonment | 1 to 2 emails | None | Intent too low for the cost |
| Back in stock | One email | One text | Customer asked for an alert |
| Post-purchase | Full series | Delivery or how-to text only | Product needs setup or has a usage window |
| Win-back | 2 to 3 emails | One final text | High value or long purchase history |
Each flow above is covered elsewhere in depth. For the abandoned cart email sequence, see abandoned cart emails without discounts. For the full flow build order, see the eight email flows every Shopify store needs. A post-purchase flow rarely needs promotional texts, and a win-back campaign only justifies one for customers worth the cost.
How do you split a campaign launch across email and SMS?
One-off campaigns follow the same logic, with time as the variable. An illustrative launch-day plan for a new product:
| When | Email audience | SMS audience |
|---|---|---|
| Day before | None | Top value segment: early access link |
| Launch morning | All engaged subscribers | None |
| Launch afternoon | None | SMS subscribers who clicked the email but didn’t buy |
| Last day of offer | Engaged non-buyers | Engaged SMS subscribers who haven’t bought |
Early access by text rewards your best customers, and the afternoon text goes only to people who showed interest. That’s the SMS campaign at its best: small, targeted and timed.
Use your preference center to collect zero-party data, such as which channel a customer prefers for launches versus order updates. When a customer tells you they want launches by email only, respect it.
How do you set this up in Klaviyo?
The same logic works in Attentive, Postscript or another ESP and SMS combination, with different menus. In Klaviyo:
- Add a channel split at the top of each flow. Use a conditional split on whether the profile can receive SMS marketing. Build the email path first, then the SMS steps on the “yes” branch.
- Add an activity check before each text. Use a conditional split on whether the profile has clicked an email, visited the site or placed an order since the flow started.
- Add flow filters for purchase exits. Use “Placed Order zero times since starting this flow” on abandonment and promotional flows.
- Build a “recently messaged” segment for campaigns, and exclude it from promotional texts.
How do you measure email and SMS together?
Platform-attributed revenue tells you which channel touched the order last. It doesn’t tell you whether the text caused it. Two measures fix that.
Revenue per subscriber by channel status. Compare revenue per profile for email-only, SMS-only and both groups over the same period. It shows whether the “both” group is worth what you spend on it.
A holdout on the SMS step. Randomly hold back a share of eligible profiles from the text and compare orders. This is basic incrementality testing.
Worked example (illustrative numbers)
A store’s checkout abandonment flow reaches 7,000 profiles a month who are subscribed to both channels and didn’t click the first email. The SMS step goes to 90% of them, and 10% are held out.
- Purchase rate with the text: 6.0%. Purchase rate in the holdout: 5.0%.
- Incremental lift: 1 percentage point × 6,300 texted profiles = 63 extra orders.
- At $30 contribution margin per order, that’s $1,890 in incremental margin.
- At an assumed $0.02 per text, 6,300 texts cost $126.
Here the text pays for itself many times over. If the same test on browse abandonment showed no difference, the SMS tool would still report attributed revenue, but the holdout would tell you to remove that step.
What should you check before you launch?
- [ ] Email and SMS consent are stored separately, with source and timestamp.
- [ ] Every flow has a channel split, with email as the default path.
- [ ] Every SMS step has an activity condition (no click, visit or purchase).
- [ ] A purchase exits both channels from abandonment and promotional flows within minutes.
- [ ] A cross-channel frequency rule exists for campaigns.
- [ ] Transactional texts carry no promotional content.
- [ ] Revenue per subscriber is reported by channel status.
- [ ] At least one SMS step is running with a holdout group.
FAQ
Should I send the same message by email and SMS?
Rarely. If both are justified, send the email first and text only those who didn’t act. The exception is a genuinely urgent message, such as a delivery problem, where speed matters more than cost.
Is SMS better than email for flows?
Neither is better across the board. SMS is faster and more interruptive and costs money per message. Email is cheap and carries more content. Use SMS where timing or value justifies the cost, and confirm with a holdout test.
What do I do with SMS-only subscribers?
Give them a shorter flow program by text and ask for their email address early, for example in the first text or on the order confirmation page. Once they’re on both channels, move them into the standard rules.