- CAC is acquisition spend divided by new customers, not by all orders. Dividing by every buyer, including repeat customers, makes acquisition look cheaper than it is.
- Decide once which costs go in (media, agency fees, creative, influencer and affiliate costs) and keep the definition fixed, so month-to-month changes mean something.
- Use blended new-customer CAC for budget decisions and channel CAC for in-channel optimization. Judge both against contribution per customer, not revenue.
What is customer acquisition cost in eCommerce?
Customer acquisition cost (CAC) is what you spend to win one new customer. For an online store, the basic formula is:
CAC = acquisition costs in a period ÷ new customers acquired in that period
The formula is simple. The mistakes happen in the two inputs: which costs you count and who you count as a new customer. Get either wrong and the number drifts, so a team can believe acquisition is getting cheaper while it is getting more expensive.
CAC matters because it is half of the unit economics question every growing store has to answer: does a new customer bring in more contribution over time than it cost to acquire them? The other half is customer lifetime value, measured on contribution, not revenue.
What is the difference between blended CAC and new-customer CAC?
The terms are used loosely, so define them inside your team and write the definitions down. These are the versions we use.
| Metric | Formula | What it answers | Blind spot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost per order | Total marketing spend ÷ all orders | What marketing costs per order shipped | Mixes in repeat buyers who cost little to win back |
| Blended new-customer CAC | Total acquisition spend ÷ all new customers | What a new customer costs across every channel, paid and unpaid | Does not show which channel is efficient |
| Paid new-customer CAC | Paid media spend ÷ new customers from paid channels | What a new customer costs through ads | Depends on attribution, which over-credits or under-credits channels |
| Channel CAC | Channel spend ÷ new customers attributed to that channel | Which channel or campaign wins customers more cheaply | Platforms claim the same customer more than once |
| Fully loaded CAC | Acquisition spend plus acquisition team and tools ÷ new customers | The true cost of the acquisition function | Harder to calculate monthly |
The most common error is reporting cost per order and calling it CAC. If half your orders come from returning customers, cost per order can look half as high as true new-customer CAC. Returning customers are mostly won back by email, SMS and organic visits, so they dilute the number without telling you anything about acquisition.
Blended new-customer CAC is the honest top-line figure. It includes every new customer, whether they came from an ad, organic search or a friend’s recommendation. That is a feature: ads often create demand that converts through search or direct visits, and blended CAC captures the full effect without arguing about attribution.
Which costs belong in customer acquisition cost?
Pick a definition and keep it stable. A CAC that includes agency fees one month and leaves them out the next is not a trend.
| Cost | Include in CAC? | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Paid media (Meta, Google, TikTok, other ad platforms) | Yes | The core of every version |
| Agency or freelancer fees for acquisition work | Yes | Leave out if you report media-only CAC, but label it |
| Creative production for ads | Yes | Shoots, editing, UGC creator fees |
| Influencer fees and product seeding | Yes | Include the cost of free product sent |
| Affiliate commissions on new-customer orders | Yes | Commissions on repeat orders belong in retention costs |
| Acquisition tools (ad management, attribution) | Fully loaded only | Small, but adds up |
| Acquisition team salaries | Fully loaded only | Useful for annual planning |
| First-order discounts | Usually no | Treat as a reduction in first-order margin instead, and be consistent |
| Email, SMS and loyalty program costs | No | These serve existing customers; count them in retention |
Discounts deserve a note. A 20% welcome offer is a real cost of acquiring a customer, but it already shows up as lower revenue on the first order. Counting it in CAC as well would count it twice. Keep it in the margin side of the calculation and look at first-order contribution after discount.
How do you count new customers correctly?
The denominator causes more errors than the costs do. A new customer is someone whose first-ever order with you falls in the period, not someone who bought in the period.
- Use first-order date across the full customer history. A customer who last bought two years ago is returning, not new.
- Deduplicate. Guest checkouts with the same email, or a customer who used two emails, can count twice. Match on email at minimum, and on phone or address where you can.
- Watch for migrations. If you moved platforms, for example from WooCommerce to Shopify, customers imported without their order history can look new. Keep the old order data available for the check.
- Exclude what is not acquisition. Wholesale accounts, marketplace orders, staff orders and replacement orders should not count as new customers.
- Count customers, not first orders. A new customer who places two orders in the same month is still one new customer.
Most platforms can export orders with a customer ID or email and a created date. A spreadsheet with first-order date per customer is enough to start.
How do you calculate CAC? A worked example
All numbers below are illustrative.
A store reviews one month of acquisition.
- Paid media: $60,000 (Meta, Google and TikTok combined)
- Agency fees and creative production: $8,000
- Total orders: 3,000
- Orders from customers whose first-ever order was this month: 1,200
- Unique new customers (some placed two orders): 1,100
Now compare the versions.
- Cost per order: $68,000 ÷ 3,000 = $22.67. This is the number that often gets reported as CAC, and it is wrong for that purpose.
- Media-only new-customer CAC: $60,000 ÷ 1,100 = $54.55.
- Blended new-customer CAC: $68,000 ÷ 1,100 = $61.82.
The difference between $22.67 and $61.82 changes every decision downstream. Now check it against margin. If the average first order from a new customer is $75 and contribution margin is 45%, the first order contributes $33.75. The store recovers a little more than half its CAC on the first purchase. The rest has to come from repeat orders, which is why CAC payback period and second-order rate matter as much as CAC itself.
How should you use CAC alongside LTV and payback?
CAC on its own says nothing about whether acquisition is healthy. A $100 CAC is fine for a store whose customers contribute $300 over a year and a problem for one whose customers buy once.
- Compare CAC with contribution-based LTV. The LTV:CAC ratio only works when LTV is measured in contribution after product, shipping, fees and returns. Our guide to customer lifetime value shows how to calculate it by cohort.
- Track payback. How many months until cumulative contribution from a cohort covers its CAC? Shorter payback means you can reinvest faster.
- Watch marginal CAC, not just average CAC. Each extra dollar of spend usually buys customers at a higher cost than the average. If blended CAC rises when you raise budgets, the last dollars are more expensive than the first. Look at CAC by spend level over several months before you scale.
- Pair CAC with MER. The marketing efficiency ratio (total revenue ÷ total marketing spend) shows the whole-business picture, while new-customer CAC shows whether you are actually growing the customer base.
Why does platform CAC differ from blended CAC?
Add up the new customers each ad platform claims and you will often get more than the new customers in your store. Each platform counts conversions under its own attribution rules and windows, and several platforms can claim the same buyer. Platforms also cannot see customers who converted through organic search or direct visits after seeing an ad.
Use platform CAC to compare campaigns and creatives inside one platform. Use blended new-customer CAC from your own store data to set budgets. When the two disagree, an incrementality test tells you how many of the claimed customers the channel actually caused.
Checklist: a CAC number you can trust
- [ ] CAC is written down with a fixed formula and a list of included costs.
- [ ] The denominator is unique new customers, based on first-ever order date.
- [ ] Customers are deduplicated by email and, where possible, phone or address.
- [ ] Wholesale, marketplace, staff and replacement orders are excluded.
- [ ] Agency, creative, influencer and affiliate costs are included or explicitly labeled as excluded.
- [ ] First-order discounts are handled in margin, not double-counted in CAC.
- [ ] Blended new-customer CAC is reported monthly alongside channel CAC.
- [ ] CAC is compared with first-order contribution and with contribution-based LTV.
- [ ] CAC is tracked against spend level to spot rising marginal cost.
FAQ
What is a good customer acquisition cost for an online store?
There is no universal number. A good CAC is one your customers repay through contribution within a payback period your cash flow can handle. Compare CAC with your own first-order contribution and your 12-month contribution per customer rather than with outside averages.
Should I include organic and referral customers in CAC?
Yes, in blended new-customer CAC. Paid campaigns often create demand that converts through organic search, direct visits or word of mouth, and blended CAC captures that. Keep paid and channel CAC as separate views for optimization.
How often should I calculate CAC?
Monthly is a good default for budget reviews, with a rolling three-month view to smooth out seasonality and launches. Weekly CAC is noisy for most stores, especially when a single creative or promotion swings results.