CAC tells you what each new customer really costs. The key word is new. Many ad platforms report cost per purchase, which includes returning customers who would likely have bought anyway. True CAC only counts first-time buyers, which you can identify in Shopify by customer order history.
Brands typically track two versions. Blended CAC divides all acquisition spend (ads, agency fees, influencer costs, creative production) by all new customers. Paid CAC divides only paid media spend by new customers attributed to paid channels. Blended CAC is harder to flatter and better for business decisions.
Why it matters for eCommerce
CAC only makes sense next to the profit a customer brings. If the contribution margin from a first order covers CAC, growth funds itself. If it doesn’t, you depend on repeat purchases, which makes your LTV:CAC ratio and retention the deciding factors for profitable scaling.
How to calculate it
CAC = total acquisition spend ÷ number of new customers acquired. For example (illustrative numbers): a store that spends $30,000 on acquisition in a month and gains 600 new customers has a CAC of $50.
Common mistakes
- Dividing spend by all orders, including returning customers, which makes CAC look lower than it is.
- Leaving out creative, agency or tool costs.
- Judging CAC without comparing it to first-order contribution margin and customer lifetime value.