Email Marketing

Email and SMS Together: Who Gets What, and When

Email and SMS work best as one program, not two. Learn how to decide which message goes to which channel, avoid double sends and measure combined results.

TL;DR
  • Treat email and SMS as one retention program with one calendar, not two teams sending to the same customers.
  • Use email for most messages and SMS for time-sensitive, high-value moments where a short text adds something email cannot.
  • Prevent double sends with suppression rules, and measure the combined effect with holdouts instead of adding each channel's attributed revenue.

Why do email and SMS need coordination?

Many stores add SMS on top of an existing email program. Soon, customers receive a cart reminder by email and by text within minutes, or a sale announcement three times in one day. Each channel looks good in its own report, but customers feel spammed and unsubscribe from both.

SMS also costs more per message than email and has stricter rules. Under U.S. rules like the TCPA, text marketing requires express written consent. Overusing SMS wastes money and creates compliance risk. See SMS compliance.

Good coordination means each customer gets the right message on the right channel, without overlap.

Which messages belong in which channel?

Message type Email SMS Why
Welcome and brand story Primary Short welcome only Email has room for content
Cart and checkout reminders First reminder Second reminder, for SMS subscribers Timely nudge
Browse abandonment Primary Rarely Low intent for a text
Order and shipping updates Primary Optional delivery alerts Customers like delivery texts
Launches and restocks Primary VIP or waitlist only Urgency for high-intent customers
Major sale start and last hours Primary Yes Time-sensitive
Content and education Primary No Too long for SMS
Back in stock Yes Yes, if opted in Time-sensitive, high intent

A good rule: if the message is urgent and valuable to the customer right now, consider SMS. If it is informational or long, use email.

How do you avoid double sends?

Set clear rules in your platform:

  • Channel priority in flows: for example, send the cart email first, then the SMS only if the email was not clicked after a few hours.
  • Suppression windows: if a customer received an SMS today, do not send another promotional SMS within a set period.
  • Campaign exclusions: SMS campaigns go to SMS subscribers who are most engaged or most valuable, not the whole SMS list for every email campaign.
  • Purchase exits: remove customers from both email and SMS sequences as soon as they buy.

Many platforms that handle both channels let you build mixed flows with conditional splits. That is easier than coordinating two separate tools.

How should you plan the calendar?

Use one shared calendar for both channels. For each campaign, decide:

  1. Is this message worth sending by SMS at all?
  2. Which SMS segment receives it (VIPs, recent buyers, high-intent browsers)?
  3. When does it go out relative to the email?

Many brands send far fewer SMS campaigns than email campaigns, for example one or two texts per month outside peak periods, while emails go out weekly. Your email send frequency and SMS cadence should be planned together.

How do you measure combined performance?

Each platform attributes revenue to its own messages. A customer who receives an email and an SMS before purchasing may be counted twice, once by each channel. Adding them together overstates results.

Better measurement:

  • Holdout groups that receive no SMS (but still get email) show what SMS adds on top of email. See holdout groups.
  • Revenue per subscriber for customers on both channels versus email only, compared over time.
  • Unsubscribe and opt-out rates on both channels, to catch fatigue early.
  • Cost per SMS conversion, since SMS has a real cost per message.

Use SMS marketing metrics to track the SMS side in detail.

Worked example: fixing an overlapping cart flow

(Illustrative numbers.) A fashion store sends a cart email after 1 hour and an SMS after 1 hour, both to customers subscribed to both channels. SMS opt-outs are rising, and reported revenue from both channels together exceeds the store’s actual cart recovery.

Changes:

  1. Email reminder after 1 hour for everyone.
  2. SMS reminder after 4 hours, only if the email was not clicked and the customer is subscribed to SMS.
  3. Second email after 24 hours if still no purchase.
  4. A 10% holdout of SMS subscribers receives emails only.

After six weeks:

  • SMS sends in the cart flow drop by 55%, cutting SMS costs.
  • SMS opt-out rate from cart messages falls.
  • Recovered revenue per cart is only slightly lower than before, and the holdout shows SMS still adds a modest incremental lift.

The store keeps the new sequence. For the SMS side of cart recovery, see SMS abandoned cart.

Checklist: email and SMS coordination

  • [ ] One shared calendar for email and SMS campaigns
  • [ ] Clear rules for which message types use SMS
  • [ ] SMS sent to engaged or high-value segments, not the full list every time
  • [ ] Flows use conditional splits to avoid simultaneous email and SMS
  • [ ] Suppression windows limit promotional SMS frequency
  • [ ] Customers exit both channels’ sequences after purchase
  • [ ] Express written consent collected for SMS marketing
  • [ ] Holdout group measures SMS impact on top of email
  • [ ] Revenue reported without double counting across channels
  • [ ] Opt-out and unsubscribe rates reviewed monthly

FAQ

Should every email campaign also go out by SMS?

No. Most email campaigns are better as emails only. Reserve SMS for time-sensitive, high-value messages and for segments that respond well to texts.

What should go first, email or SMS?

In most flows, email first, then SMS as a follow-up if the customer has not acted. For urgent moments like the final hours of a sale or a limited restock, SMS can lead.

How do I know if SMS is adding value beyond email?

Use a holdout group of SMS subscribers who receive only emails. Compare revenue per customer between the groups over several weeks. That shows the incremental value of SMS more reliably than platform attribution.

Turn this into a plan for your store

The Free Profit Audit scans your store, sizes your biggest profit leaks and builds a 90-day plan.

Free Profit Audit