Growth Strategy

Checkout Payment Methods: Wallets, Buy Now Pay Later and What to Offer

The right payment options reduce checkout friction. Learn which methods matter for U.S. shoppers, when buy now pay later helps and how to measure it.

TL;DR
  • Shoppers abandon checkout when their preferred payment method is missing or when entering card details feels slow.
  • Cover the basics (major cards, digital wallets such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and Shop Pay where available), then consider buy now pay later for higher-priced orders.
  • Show payment options early, keep checkout fast on mobile and measure conversion and AOV by payment method.

Why do payment options affect conversion?

Payment is the last step of the purchase, and small frictions there have a big effect:

  • Typing card details on a phone is slow and error-prone.
  • Shoppers who prefer a wallet or a specific method may leave if it is missing.
  • Some shoppers hesitate at larger order values and look for ways to split payments.

The goal is not to offer every possible method, but to offer the ones your customers expect, in a checkout that feels fast and safe. See Shopify checkout optimization.

Which payment methods should a U.S. store offer?

Method Why it matters Typical use
Credit and debit cards Still the baseline for most shoppers Every store
Apple Pay and Google Pay Fast mobile checkout without typing card details Mobile shoppers
PayPal Familiar, trusted by many shoppers Broad audiences
Shop Pay (on Shopify) Saved details across Shopify stores, fast checkout Shopify stores
Buy now pay later Splits payments, can lift conversion on higher-priced items Orders above a certain value
Gift cards and store credit Supports gifting and returns Most stores

Your platform and payment provider determine what is available. Check fees, payout timing and dispute handling for each method.

When does buy now pay later make sense?

Buy now pay later (BNPL) services such as Klarna, Afterpay and Affirm let shoppers split a purchase into installments. The store usually receives the full amount up front and pays the provider a fee.

BNPL tends to fit:

  • Higher-priced products, such as furniture, electronics, premium apparel and beauty sets.
  • Audiences familiar with installment payments.
  • Promotions where a lower per-payment price helps the decision.

Watch out for:

  • Fees: BNPL fees are often higher than card processing fees. Check whether the extra conversion and AOV cover the cost.
  • Messaging: show installment pricing (for example “4 payments of $25”) clearly and accurately, near the price and in checkout.
  • Return handling: make sure refunds and BNPL plans are handled correctly.

How should payment options be shown?

  • Show accepted methods early: payment icons on product pages and in the cart reassure shoppers before checkout.
  • Express checkout buttons: place wallet buttons (Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Shop Pay) at the top of checkout and, where helpful, in the cart.
  • Installment messaging: show BNPL messaging near the price on product pages for eligible items.
  • Avoid clutter: too many logos and buttons can slow the page and confuse shoppers.

Payment security cues also matter. See trust signals for eCommerce.

How do you measure the impact?

Track by payment method:

  • Share of orders.
  • Conversion rate of checkout sessions where the method was shown.
  • Average order value.
  • Return and refund rate.
  • Fees as a percentage of revenue.
  • Chargeback and dispute rate.

When adding a method, compare checkout conversion and AOV before and after, or run an A/B test if your platform supports it. Remember that fees and AOV both affect profit.

Worked example: adding BNPL for a furniture store

(Illustrative numbers.) A furniture store with an average order value of $640 offers cards and PayPal only. Many shoppers abandon at checkout, and support receives questions about financing.

Changes:

  1. Add a BNPL provider with installment messaging on product pages above $200.
  2. Add Apple Pay and Google Pay express buttons.
  3. Track checkout conversion, AOV and fees for eight weeks versus the previous eight weeks, adjusted for seasonality.

Results:

  • About 18% of orders use BNPL.
  • AOV for BNPL orders is noticeably higher than for card orders.
  • Overall checkout conversion rises modestly.
  • BNPL fees are higher than card fees, but the extra orders and higher AOV more than cover them in gross profit.

The store keeps BNPL and tests showing installment messaging in the cart as well.

Checklist: checkout payment methods

  • [ ] Major cards accepted
  • [ ] Apple Pay and Google Pay enabled for mobile checkout
  • [ ] PayPal or Shop Pay offered if relevant to your audience
  • [ ] BNPL considered for higher-priced products, with fees modeled
  • [ ] Installment messaging accurate and shown near prices
  • [ ] Express checkout buttons placed at the top of checkout
  • [ ] Payment icons shown on product and cart pages
  • [ ] Conversion, AOV, fees and returns tracked by payment method
  • [ ] Dispute and chargeback rates monitored
  • [ ] Payment options reviewed at least once a year

FAQ

Does adding more payment methods always increase conversion?

Not always. Adding the methods your customers expect usually helps, but adding many rarely used options can clutter checkout. Check customer preferences and test changes.

Is buy now pay later worth the higher fees?

It can be for higher-priced products, if it increases conversion and order value enough to cover the fees. Model the economics and measure results after launch.

Should express checkout buttons appear on product pages?

They can speed up purchase for single-item orders, but they may reduce cross-sells and bundle purchases. Test placement on product pages versus cart and checkout only.

Turn this into a plan for your store

The Free Profit Audit scans your store, sizes your biggest profit leaks and builds a 90-day plan.

Free Profit Audit